Get On With The Killing!
Plot Vs Backstory.
This is probably more relevant to ongoing series than standalones, but it can apply to both.
A complaint that I’ve seen both in online discussion forums and reader reviews for particular books, is that readers felt there was too much of the characters’ history and personal lives, and that they just wanted the detective to get on and catch the bad guy. They’ve picked up a mystery or thriller; they aren’t interested in the lead detective’s ongoing marital strife.
On the flipside, I’ve also seen readers enthusiastically talking about the characters’ tangled private lives, and speculating about where things will go next. I have a few regular readers who are kind enough to message me about my books and ask for hints about what will happen to Warren and his wife Susan. Naturally, I politely thank them but keep my cards hidden.
Ordinarily, I usually suggest writers try and find a balance between the two – but really that advice is about as much use as a chocolate teapot. Because where is that balance? Every series is different. At the two ends of the spectrum, there are series where readers come back each time to see how their favourite characters – who are now more like friends – are getting on. The grisly murder at the heart of the book is almost an afterthought. Then there is the opposite end of the spectrum, where it’s all about the mystery. The characters’ private lives are an unwelcome distraction, and they are emotionally constipated.
Then there is everything in between.
The simple fact of the matter, is that you are never going to please everyone. That’s life. I have read reviews of award-winning authors, lauded by readers and their peers, where somebody has given the book 3 stars and grumbled that it could have been half the length if only a good editor had cut the fluff about the detective’s dying wife. There are also highly-regarded writers that have stood the test of time, that are criticised for the lack of characterisation in their books.
So I am going to give you one bit of advice:
Write what feels right; write what you want to read. Find your own balance.
By all means listen to constructive criticism from those you respect (over the years, my editors have variously told me to cut paragraphs that don’t add to the main plot, or expand upon aspects of a character that readers may find interesting.) But ultimately, the balance between the solving of the crimes at the centre of my books and the trials and tribulations of DCI Warren Jones and his team at Middlesbury CID is what I feel comfortable with.
What are your views on plot vs backstory? As always feel free to share your thoughts in the comments or on social media.
Until next time,
Paul
